Hockey History

Defenseman Joe Matte was one of the stars of the Tigers,
and stayed with the club when it was in the NHL in the
early 1920s. Photo courtesy of the Hamilton Spectator. |
The 1919 Allan Cup– Chapter 1
The Tigers get tuned up, clobbering the Toronto Veterans
13-3
Before the Hamilton Tigers went professional in 1920 during their
five-year term as an NHL club, the OHA senior team was a good one,
and by 1919 was a contender for the Allan Cup, the top prize in
Canadian amateur hockey.
To give an idea of the team’s capabilities, here’s
the results of a game played early in 1919 as the team began to
gear up for the playoffs.
Pre-game talk for a game in Hamilton against the Toronto Veterans
was favorable for Hamilton, who not only had Shorty Green on the
squad, but had just acquired the talents of Bill Duncan, who played
left wing for the AAF team. He was also a hockey friend of Green
from Sudbury, where they had both played.
“Hockey is king in local sporting circles,” noted
a newspaper account before the match. “One all sides one
can hear nothing but discussions on the senior OHA outlook, and
Tigers’ prospects of winning the championship.”
The game was quite a one-sided affair, with Hamilton defeating
Toronto 13-3. Although the Vets scored first at the 17-second mark
of the first, and twice more in the period, they were helpless
as they watched the Tigers scored nine goals in the second and
third periods to add to their four-goal first period. Future Montreal
Canadien Herb Reaume was in net for the Tigers.
Substitute winger Thomas McCarthy had an outstanding game for
Hamilton, scoring eight goals himself, playing with center Mickey
Roach:
“There is no getting away from the fact that Roach and McCarthy
stood heads above the other players,” reported the Hamilton
Spectator. “They played like Siamese twins and McCarthy scored
eight of the 13 goals noted by the yellow and black, the majority
of them on a pass from his running mate Roach.”
The account continued that although the Tigers were a strong team,
there was still work to be done to continue towards the championship:
“The game showed that Tigers have the material for a championship
team, but there remains a great deal to be done in the way of whipping
it into shape. While the Tigers had more sped than the visitors
the Vets proved hard checkers, and were at the heels of the locals
all the time.”
And the visiting press was not impressed with the facility the
game was held in, considering the quality of hockey.
“The attendance at the Hamilton-Veteran game in Hamilton
last night indicates that the Ambitious City must be accorded a
place on the hockey map,” stated the Toronto Globe. “The
rink is small, and the accommodation for the spectators is not
what a city of Hamilton’s size and sporting proclivities
warrants. With hockey properly handled, the present plant with
its artificial ice apparatus will have to be enlarged of a more
commodious rink erected.”
Well, the Barton Street arena, built in 1912-13 would remain the
rink for all major hockey played in the city for close to the next
60 years. Although enlarged and updated, Hamilton fans would have
to tolerate the arena until the building of Copps Coliseum.
Next: On the road to the Allan Cup, Hamilton meets its first opponent,
an opponent with a name that ranks as one of the oddest in the
sport.
BACK
HOME
|